Your Guide To All Things Beauty and Makeup | Sign Up

Makeup

Best Colourful Mascara: Our Top Recommedations

By Sophie Joaman • October 24, 2024 • 6 mins read



Mascara is a staple in most beauty routines, but that doesn’t mean it has to be limited to classic black mascara or brown. Adding a pop of colour to your lash routine can make a bold statement and really bring the glamour to the party. Coloured mascara, whether it’s a subtle tint or a vibrant hue, can truly elevate your makeup game, giving your style a fresh makeover. Whether you’re looking for a subtle burst of colour or something more high-impact, there’s a color mascara out there for everyone.

No matter what shade you choose or how pigmented the mascara formula is, we believe there’s one that will suit your style perfectly. Plus, they look incredibly stunning for just about every moment. Whether you’ve dabbled with coloured mascara in the past or have never even considered it before reading this article, take this as your sign to give it a try. We’ve curated a list of some of the best colourful mascaras out there—including options from top brands like YSL—to make it easier for you to choose, and we’re confident they’ll brighten up even the greyest of days.

Best Colourful Mascaras

Pat McGrath Labs Dark Star Colour Blitz Mascara – Best Pigment

The Pat McGrath Labs Dark Star Colour Blitz Mascara is out of this world when it comes to colour mascara wow factor. Renowned for its exquisite pigment, this mascara gives your lashes stand-out drama. Think 80s glam rock meets contemporary glamour; this mascara was made for statement makeup looks—perfect for nights out and special occasions. The best thing about this mascara is how striking the hues look on your lashes. If vibrant and bold is what you’re looking for, then vibrant and bold is what you’ll get.

While the pigment is exceptional, it can, however, be a bit of a double-edged sword, as it may be harder to remove compared to less pigmented options. Be mindful that you will likely need a good makeup remover, especially if you’re using bold coloured mascara.

Pat McGrath Labs vibrant pink mascara tube and applicator, designed to enhance lashes with bold color and volume for a dramatic eye look.

By Terry Mascara Terrybly – Best Long-Lasting

By Terry Mascara Terrybly wins us over for its longevity. Its formula is designed to last throughout the day without flaking or smudging, making it a reliable choice for those who need staying power from their mascara. If you’re after a subtle pop of colour mascara that lasts beautifully from morning to night, this mascara is a solid choice. In terms of pigment, this mascara offers a more subtle effect. It is available in just four shades, with two—blue and brown—being relatively conventional for mascara. If you’re seeking something bolder and richer in hue, this mascara might not give you the desired effect.

Mascara TERRYBLY product

Shiseido Controlled Chaos MascaraInk – Best Buildable

The Shiseido Controlled Chaos MascaraInk is ideal for those who enjoy customizing their look by building it up. This mascara features a fully buildable formula, allowing you to control the application to achieve the desired volume and length. With this mascara, you can create a variety of versatile looks, from a natural swipe of colour mascara for everyday wear to something much more dramatic. It also feels weightless on the lashes, preventing clumping, flaking, and sagging.

However, because it’s buildable, it may take a bit longer to achieve your desired effect. This could be a drawback for those seeking a quick and easy solution.

from a luxury or high-end beauty brand, with a distinctive purple brush. The packaging looks sleek and modern, with a black tube and red detailing. It could be a product from a well-known brand like Shiseido

YSL Beauty Lash Clash Mascara – Best Luxury

The YSL Beauty Lash Clash Mascara epitomises luxury. With its sleek and elegant design and high-performance formula, this is the choice for beauty enthusiasts looking for high-end style and substance. The formula is made all the more luxurious with iris extract and delivers gorgeous, voluminous, coloured mascara lashes that look incredibly sophisticated. However, with its luxury price tag, it’s not the most budget-friendly option. If you’re experimenting with color mascara for the first time, it might feel like a gamble, especially if you’re unsure about the hue.

featuring a black casing with a blue ribbon design. The mascara wand is straight with a standard brush for application.

KIKO Milano Smart Colour Mascara – Best Colour Range

IKO Milano’s Smart Colour Mascara excels in colour mascara choice, offering an impressive range of shades from deep purples to vibrant greens. Whether you’re using it as a top coat over your regular black mascara or on its own, this coloured mascara is a fantastic option for experimenting. It lets you try out different looks, helping you find your perfect hue or even start a collection to match your outfits or moods.

On the downside, there are other mascaras that may work better for various lash types. The brush on this one is fairly standard, so if you need extra help with curl or lift for short lashes, this mascara might not perform as well as those specifically designed for that purpose.

a mascara from KIKO Milano, known for its vibrant packaging in a burgundy color. The product is labeled as a "Smart Color Mascara," suggesting it may come in various shades or offer special effects for a unique look.

DIORSHOW Pump ‘N’ Volume – Best Volume

The DIORSHOW Pump ‘N’ Volume certainly lives up to its name by offering XXL volume to your lashes. The intense ‘ink’ coats the lashes for a fuller look for up to 24 hours. If you have short lashes and crave that thick volume look, this mascara will help give you that ‘false lash’ effect with just a couple of coats. The innovative formula and applicator also fan the lashes out to complement your eyes, delivering plump lashes as well as dramatic volume.

Dior's iconic Diorshow Mascara. The packaging is sleek, black with the signature Dior logo, and the brush has a traditional design with thick, bristled fibers, likely for volume and lengthening.

One thing to note is that this might not be the mascara for you if you are looking for an ‘edgy’ vibe. In this range, the shade choices are considerably more classic, perfect for everyday wear and special occasions. For a more adventurous look, you might be better off with one of the other options. Nevertheless, this mascara is exceptional if you are looking for a pop of colour and endless volume.

Colourful mascara is a fun and exciting way to experiment with makeup and add a unique twist to your look. If we had to choose just one from our list, we’d go for the Pat McGrath Labs Dark Star Colour Blitz Mascara. If we’re going to add some extra colour to our makeup, we may as well go big or go home. The rich pigments deliver exceptional drama and glamour, making it the perfect choice when you want your makeup to tell a story. At the end of the day, trying something new is always

Author Image

Sophie Joaman

Sophie Joaman is a freelance writer with a real love and focus for fashion, beauty, lifestyle and culture. With a Master's degree in Journalism and Media Communications, Sophie is ​​currently an ongoing contributing freelance writer for Cohorted Cult-sister website of beauty subscription box Cohorted. She was also a contributing writer during London Fashion Week and London Fashion Week: Men's from 2015-2018.

Related Posts

Makeup

How To Remove Waterproof Mascara In 4 Simple Steps


26 Aug 2024
Makeup

Skin Minimalism for Lasting Radiance: The Extraordinary Power of Less


10 Mar 2025
Makeup

The 6 Best Lip Liners For All Lip Combos


30 Jun 2024